Study tips

Nucleophilic substitution: curly arrows

Rich walks through the mechanism for bromoethane and the cyanide ion: the lone pair attacks the δ+ carbon and the C–Br bond breaks, giving propanenitrile.

In short: In nucleophilic substitution, the nucleophile uses a lone pair to attack the δ+ carbon, and the C–Br bond breaks heterolytically, with both electrons going to bromine. Every curly arrow shows a pair of electrons moving, so it must start at a lone pair or a bond.

Curly arrows lose students marks even when they understand the reaction, usually because an arrow starts or ends in the wrong place. Here is the method I teach, using bromoethane and the cyanide ion.

The example: bromoethane and cyanide

CH₃CH₂Br + CN⁻ → CH₃CH₂CN + Br⁻

The product is propanenitrile. The carbon chain has grown by one carbon, which makes this a useful reaction in synthesis.

Drawing the mechanism, step by step

  1. Show the nucleophile. Draw CN⁻ with its lone pair on the carbon atom and the negative charge. The lone pair on the carbon is what attacks.
  2. Show the polar bond. Bromine is more electronegative than carbon, so the C–Br bond is polar. Mark δ+ on the carbon and δ− on the bromine.
  3. First arrow. Draw it from the lone pair on the carbon of CN⁻ to the δ+ carbon. This forms a new C–C bond.
  4. Second arrow. Draw it from the middle of the C–Br bond to the bromine atom. This shows the bond breaking with both electrons going to bromine.
  5. Show the products. Propanenitrile and a bromide ion, Br⁻.

The C–Br bond breaks by heterolytic fission: both electrons go to the bromine, which leaves as a bromide ion, the leaving group.

Rich's tip: Every curly arrow shows a pair of electrons moving. Make sure each one starts at a lone pair or a bond.

Rules for where arrows start and end

  • An arrow starts at a lone pair or at a covalent bond. It never starts at an atom or at a charge on its own.
  • An arrow ends at an atom (where a new bond forms or a lone pair is formed) or in the space between two atoms (where a new bond forms).
  • The arrow head shows where the pair of electrons goes. It is a full-headed arrow, because a pair is moving.
  • Draw arrows from the nucleophile towards the δ+ carbon, never the other way round.

Other nucleophiles

The same pattern works with other nucleophiles. Only the lone pair and the product change.

  • Hydroxide ion, OH⁻. The lone pair on the oxygen attacks the δ+ carbon. The product is ethanol, CH₃CH₂OH. The usual conditions are heating under reflux with aqueous sodium or potassium hydroxide.
  • Ammonia, NH₃. The lone pair on the nitrogen attacks the δ+ carbon. The product is an amine, ethylamine, CH₃CH₂NH₂. Ammonia is neutral, so after the attack there is an extra step in which a second ammonia molecule removes an H⁺.

Common mistakes

  • Starting an arrow at an atom or a bare charge. Start it at the lone pair.
  • Drawing the C–Br arrow to the carbon instead of to the bromine.
  • Forgetting the δ+ and δ− on the polar bond.
  • Writing the product as a nitrile with the wrong number of carbons. Count carefully: bromoethane has 2, propanenitrile has 3.

Practise it

The best way to learn arrows is to draw them again and again, with feedback. The free Chemistry Coach Toolbox has interactive chemistry tools you can use alongside your revision. Then draw the mechanism again on a blank page from memory, with your notes closed.

If you want to talk a mechanism through, Dexter, the A Level Chemistry tutor I built, can go through nucleophilic substitution with you and explain where each arrow starts and ends.

Questions students ask

Where do curly arrows start and end?

A curly arrow starts at a lone pair or a covalent bond and ends at an atom or between two atoms where a new bond forms. It shows a pair of electrons moving.

What is the mechanism for bromoethane and cyanide ions?

The lone pair on the carbon of CN⁻ attacks the δ+ carbon and forms a new C–C bond. The C–Br bond breaks heterolytically, and both electrons go to bromine, giving propanenitrile and Br⁻.

What is heterolytic fission?

Heterolytic fission is when a covalent bond breaks and both electrons in the bond go to one atom, forming a positive ion and a negative ion.

Why is cyanide used to make nitriles from halogenoalkanes?

The cyanide ion substitutes for the halogen and adds a carbon atom, so the carbon chain is one carbon longer. The product is a nitrile.