In short: In the electrophilic addition of HBr to ethene, the first curly arrow starts at the C=C double bond, where the electron density is high, and points to the δ+ hydrogen of H–Br. It does not start at the hydrogen.
Curly arrows show the movement of a pair of electrons. In mechanism questions, each arrow has to start and end in exactly the right place for the marks.
Spot the mistake
The clip shows three curly arrows in the mechanism for ethene and hydrogen bromide. Two are right. The mistake is the first arrow: it was drawn from the H to the C=C. It should be drawn from the C=C double bond to the δ+ H.
Rich's tip: Check where each arrow starts, not just where it ends.
Why alkenes react with electrophiles
The C=C double bond contains a π bond, which is an area of high electron density. That attracts an electrophile, a species that accepts a pair of electrons. In H–Br, bromine is more electronegative than hydrogen, so the H is δ+ and is attracted to the double bond.
The mechanism, step by step
CH₂=CH₂ + HBr → CH₃CH₂Br
- Arrow 1: from the C=C double bond to the δ+ hydrogen. The pair of electrons from the π bond forms a new bond between one carbon and the H.
- Arrow 2: from the H–Br bond to the Br atom. The H–Br bond breaks, and both electrons go to the bromine, forming a Br⁻ ion.
- The other carbon now has only three bonds and a positive charge. This is a carbocation, CH₃CH₂⁺.
- Arrow 3: from a lone pair on Br⁻ to the C⁺. This forms a new C–Br bond and gives the product, bromoethane.
Heterolytic fission
When the H–Br bond breaks, both electrons go to the same atom. This is called heterolytic fission, and it is why the arrow goes from the bond to the Br and produces ions. It is different from homolytic fission, where each atom takes one electron and radicals form.
Rules for drawing curly arrows
- An arrow starts at a bond or a lone pair, never at an atom or a charge.
- It ends at the atom or the place where the new bond forms.
- A full-headed arrow shows the movement of a pair of electrons.
- Draw the dipole δ+ and δ− on the H–Br bond.
- Show the lone pair on the bromide ion before you draw its arrow.
Propene and Markownikoff
With an unsymmetrical alkene such as propene, HBr can add in two ways. The major product is 2-bromopropane, because it forms through a secondary carbocation. The two alkyl groups on that carbon push electron density towards it, which makes it more stable than the primary carbocation, which has only one alkyl group. The primary route gives 1-bromopropane as the minor product. This is Markownikoff's rule: the hydrogen adds to the carbon that already has more hydrogens. The reason is the more stable carbocation.
Common mistakes
- Starting the first arrow at the hydrogen.
- Drawing an arrow from a Br atom instead of from a lone pair on Br⁻.
- Missing the charge on the carbocation.
- Using a single-headed arrow, which shows one electron and belongs to radical mechanisms.
- Calling the mechanism substitution. Here two species add together to make one product.
Where this leads
Alkenes are not the only compounds where curly arrows matter. In nucleophilic substitution the carbon is where the first arrow ends, not where it starts: it runs from a lone pair on the nucleophile to the δ+ carbon, as I explain in Nucleophilic substitution: curly arrows.
Writing it in the exam
Name the mechanism: electrophilic addition. Draw all three arrows and the intermediate, label the dipole, and name the product.
If you want to practise mechanisms, Dexter, the A Level Chemistry tutor I built, can talk you through curly arrows step by step and check where your arrows start and finish.